Catherine Keener

Amelia

Anne Heche

Laura

Todd Field

Frank

Liev Schreiber

Andrew

Kevin Corrigan

Bill

Amy Braverman

Young Amelia

Miranda Rhyne

Young Laura

Randall Batinkoff

Peter

Brenda Denmark

The Vet

Vincent Pastore

Laura's Devil-Seeing Patient

Joseph Siravo

Amelia's Therapist

Rafa Alvarez

Laura's Sexy Patient

Ritamarie Kelly

Ellen

Steve Cohen

Actor In Play

Jordan Levinson

Peter's Friend

Heather Gottlieb

Amelia's Co-Worker

Lynn Cohen

Andrew's Mom

Lawrence Holofcener

Andrew's Dad